Sexism and the City
For the first time - even though the formula has been tried a thousand times - it was a realistic, well...semi-realistic portayal of women, single women - searching for, reflecting on and struggling with...Love.
The glitz, the glamour, the ugliness, the bad things men do, the bad things women do...it was all there, it was all very real and very easy to relate to.
Witty, funny, intelligently written.
Smart.
My favorite thing about the show was the fact that the bottom line was this: The only thing Carrie, Samantha, Miranda and Charlotte EVER needed was each other. Four women who didn't need a man for validation - because validation was in their own personal success - and their close circle of friendship.
Then the movie came out.
Where to begin...?
Carrie is ditched at the altar on her wedding day - humiliated in front of almost 300 people by the guy who was nothing but a smug asshole to her the ENTIRE series. Lest we forget - Mr. Big was the guy who hurt and dumped her countless times, married someone else, only showed interest in Carrie when she found someone else who she MIGHT actually be happy with - had an affair with her and fucked that up for her and was just a stereotypical ASSHOLE throughout the series.
Likeable? No. He wasn't. I never liked Big.
"I never liked him either," Life Partner said.
So - staying true to character - he humiliates her on their wedding day - gives a lame excuse "I just didn't know that it was still you and me, honey..." and all but DESTROYS her self-esteem.
But ...he builds her a super nice closet for all her pretty girly things (what girl would't melt?) and proposes again.
And...she takes him back. Even apologizes to him for allowing herself to indulge in designer dresses and have the glamourous wedding she always dreamed of.
Poor Mr. Big. To think, she could do that to him.
Of course, the glamourous wedding was a little over the top.
"What were we thinking...? We were fine how we were!" Carrie reflects to Mr. Big.
Okay, this is interesting, I think to myself. Maybe they are just going to be common law - forget the wedding and just LIVE happily ever after.
Not the case.
Ever placing SO MUCH validity on that piece of paper - they go off to city hall to make it official. Non traditional, right?
Well - she still wore white and had on her "something blue" - designer Manolo's.
Miranda.
A hard working mother, wife and lawyer - over-whelmed with being a mommy and her work load - but clearly trying and strugging to do her best. But...not enough sex for her husband so he goes out and bangs some random woman. Of course, the poor husband just feels SO guilty about this - (awwww...poor guy!) and he confesses. She does the right thing and leaves...but of course, they go to counselling and she is convinced that perhaps she DROVE HIM TO CHEAT and that maybe she should just forget he screwed around on her and try to be less of a bitchy, over-worked mom - and just shut up and be sexually available to meet her husband's needs.
To my horror - she embraces this - forgives him, and they live happily ever after.
Great fucking message that sends.
Your husband is cheating? It's probably because you were a bitch and not fucking him enough. Quit being a bitch and open up those legs and you guys should be all set! "Forgive him now - he feels sorry, really he does (this is code for him saying: I don't want to be a bachelor and have to pay child support for the rest of my life -I want to have my cake and eat it too, like the way things were before) and live happily ever after."
Dear God.
Charlotte - happily married with an adopted baby, and pregnant for the first time (It's a miracle! She thought she couldn't have kids) and her man is a TRUE keeper. She has it all: The picture perfect family life. A stay at home mom, homemaker - always the traditional one, the least slutty one throughout the entire show - the most CONSERVATIVE woman in the group - who believes that a good wife pleases her man. She never came off as the most intelligent one - but - a good wife doesn't have to be smart, she just has to be able to maintain a nice figure, attractive home and steady dose of "sex" for her man - follow those rules, ladies - and YOU could have the Fairy Tale Marriage, just like Charlotte! After all - she only ever dreamed of meeting a man and having babies, right?
Isn't that the reason women were put on the planet?
Samantha.
She was always my favourite character because she never gave a shit. A fierce appetite for sex - hot, confident, pushing the big 5-O - and still EVERY BIT a force to be reckoned with in the arena of men (and women).
She rejects the life as a common law wife and decides all she needs is herself.
Nice. I applaud this.
But...what is it really saying?
The one girl who is all about slutting it up - OF COURSE she'll never get married...she CLEARLY has no values!
She is doomed to be childless and will NEVER attain the level of love her other, married friends will...because...well...if you're not married - you just can't be in a healthy relationship, right?
Now, I'm a guy. A gay guy - but a guy.
While gay men have a lot in common with straight women - I don't believe men are truly capable of ever understanding the way women think.
So - I asked a woman what SHE thinks of the "messages" in Sex & The City - and my good friend - a pop culture junkie like myself - pointed out that a sequel is in the works...
"Frankly, the only realistic turn of events would be Big cheating on her with a younger woman," She said - over an email conversation while both of us were at work. "I mean, really, if they are keeping in character with him, that's 100% what he'd do. I have never understood the fans of the show that, like, LOVE Big, and think he and Carrie are so meant to be - I think the show would have been better making him represent the asshole who you like almost because he treats you like shit, and is therefore unattainable. I think it would be really good if in the sequel they had Big trade Carrie in for a younger model, or have him sneaking around on her, like Carrie and Big did to Natasha. But, I'm sure we'll have them happily ever after, trendily adopting a baby from Malawi like a new handbag for Carrie or something. Ugh."
LOL!
Well said! Well said indeed.
By all means - go check out the movie...I know it's just fantasy - and there really ARE some great scenes in the movie. I enjoyed it.
But - the last 15 minutes...when Big proposed to Carrie - if she just said: "You know what? How about...NO!" and walked out, designer shoes in hand - THAT would have been a REAL "Sex & the City" ending.
Instead - we got watered down Hollywood crap with a stupid "BUT THEY WOULD NEVER DO THAT!" ending - and old fashioned "Good Housewife Guide" family values - poorly disguised in haute couture and hot pink prada bags.
*sigh*
Stop me, before I get Carried away,
Dan




